Skip to main content

"[C]orrupt Thomism...Suárez strays from Aquinas are too many and significant to ignore. To name a few: (i) On metaphysics, Suárez blurred the distinction between essence and existence in created beings, which would eventually turn him into a favorite of contemporary ontology theorists like Martin Heidegger; (ii) On free will and pre-destination...advanced “congruism,” ...notion of human freedom, eerily similar to that of political liberalism; and (iii) On legal theory, Suárez seemed to argue that law resides in God’s will rather than reason, thus opening the door to voluntarism and perhaps totalitarianism"

https://thenewdigest.substack.com/p/the-uses-of-suarez


The Uses of Suarez

A Review of Kincaid, “Law From Below: How The Thought of Francisco Suárez, SJ, Can Renew Contemporary Legal Engagement”

The New Digest is delighted to present this guest essay by Mr. Aníbal Sabater, a partner at Chaffetz Lindsey LLP, a specialist in international arbitration, and a noted commentator on classical legal themes. His previous work in our pages on constitutionalism in Spain and can be found here and here; and his posts at the Ius et Iustitium site, including a series on lawyers and law in Dante, can be found here.

The New Digest is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support our work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Share

In his 1879 Encyclical Aeterni Patris, Leo XIII urged scholars to read Aquinas directly:

“… lest the false for the true or the corrupt for the pure be drunk in, be ye watchful that the doctrine of Thomas be drawn from his own fountains, or at least from those rivulets which, derived from the very fount, have thus far flowed, according to the established agreement of learned men, pure and clear; be careful to guard the minds of youth from those which are said to flow thence, but in reality are gathered from strange and unwholesome streams.”[1]

While Leo XIII did not identify those “strange and unwholesome streams” that corrupt Thomism, a sizable list of scholars reads the charge as addressed against Francisco Suárez SJ.[2]  They may well be right, because the points on which Suárez strays from Aquinas are too many and significant to ignore. To name a few:

(i)             On metaphysics, Suárez blurred the distinction between essence and existence in created beings, which would eventually turn him into a favorite of contemporary ontology theorists like Martin Heidegger;

(ii)           On free will and pre-destination (the notorious controversy “de auxiliis”), Suárez advanced “congruism,” a position that would eventually be adopted by the Society of Jesus, but is (rightly) viewed in the Order of Preachers as calling into question God’s omnipotence and spousing both Pelagianism and a distorted notion of human freedom, eerily similar to that of political liberalism; and

(iii)         On legal theory, Suárez seemed to argue that law resides in God’s will rather than reason, thus opening the door to voluntarism and perhaps totalitarianism.


Comments

Justina said…
So, why was Scotus right?
Fred Martinez said…
AI Overview In their book Confusion in the West, John and Anna Rist explore how the phenomenologist Edith Stein drew on John Duns Scotus to frame the foundational uniqueness of the human person. The "Scotist principle" highlights that every human possesses an individual, unrepeatable core rather than just being a generic instance of a species.John Rist's discussion points center on the philosophical roots of individuality and modern societal breakdowns. The key connecting principles and figures include:The "Original Tradition": The Rists argue that Western civilization is in crisis because it has eroded its foundational "original tradition" (which combines classical philosophy and early Christian theology), leading to nihilism and consumerism.Duns Scotus on Individuality: Medieval scholastic philosopher John Duns Scotus argued against Thomas Aquinas by asserting that human uniqueness stems from a specific metaphysical essence (the haecceitas, or "thisness"). Scotus affirmed that humans are individuals in their own right, not just variations of a natural category.Stein’s Application: In her magnum opus Finite and Eternal Being, Edith Stein utilized this Scotist concept. From the "Scotist principle," she concluded that the most vital and fundamental distinction among humans is their unrepeatable personal core, providing a philosophical bedrock for human dignity that does not rely on biological reductionism.Read more about Edith Stein's phenomenological anthropology and Scotist influences via Church Life Journal or explore John Rist's arguments further on Cambridge Core.
Fred Martinez said…
https://www.thefredmartinezreport.com/2026/05/ai-overview-in-their-book-confusion-in.html

Popular posts from this blog

5 Dubia Questions for 1P5's Steve Skojec & All faithful Catholics especially Francis is definitely Pope Cardinals, Bishops & pundits

Here are five really short and easy to answer dubia questions which hopefully aren't too complicated for Steve Skojec, publisher of the One Peter Five website, to answer. To make it really easy for the publisher of One Peter Five it has been formatted so that he only has to answer: yes or no. 1. Doctor of the Church St. Francis de Sales said "The Pope... when he is explicitly a heretic... the Church must either deprive him or as some say declare him deprived of his Apostolic See." Was St. Francis de Sales a Sedevacantist or a Benevacantist? Answer: yes or no. 2. "Universal Acceptance" theologian John of St. Thomas said "This man in particular lawfully elected and accepted by the Church is the supreme pontiff." Was John of St. Thomas for saying "the supreme pontiff" must be BOTH "lawfully elected and accepted by the Church" a Sedevacantist or a Benevacantist? Answer: yes or no. 3. Do you think that a "supreme pontiff...

non veni pacem (Mark Docherty) Prevost appoints Cupich to join McCarrick roomie Farrell at the Pontifical Commission for the Vatican City State

non veni pacem (Mark Docherty) Prevost appoints Cupich to join McCarrick roomie Farrell at the Pontifical Commission for the Vatican City State Pray an Our Father now for reparation for the sins committed because of Francis’s Amoris Laetitia and  for the restoration of the Church. Stop for a moment of silence, ask Jesus Christ what He wants you to do now and next. In this silence remember God, Father, Son and Holy Ghost – Three Divine Persons yet One God, has an ordered universe where you can know truth and falsehood as well as never forget that He wants you to have eternal happiness with Him as his son or daughter by grace. Make this a practice. By doing this you are doing more good than reading anything here or anywhere else on the Internet. Conclave Notes: Has the Trad Media fallen into a COVID-like mass formation with Leo XVI? While it's humorous to see the former anti-Francis Trad pundits suddenly acting like teen age girls infatuated with Leo, it could lead to a Trojan Horse ...

LifeSite: "Prevost’s reported support...allowing divorced & civilly 'remarried'...to receive Holy Communion": “Whoever…helps...promulgation of heresy…is suspected of heresy.” --Canon 2316, Code of Canon Law (1917-1982)

“Whoever…willingly and knowingly helps in the promulgation of heresy…is suspected of heresy.” --Canon 2316,  Code of Canon Law (1917-1982) Trump congratulates Pope Leo XIV on being named first American pontiff ... .. .  While Prevost’s election to the papacy is sure to gladden a number of Americans, and  the cardinal has been  seen  as a “compromise candidate” for the papacy by the College of Cardinals, his history indicates that he may continue the heterodox positions of Pope Francis.  This includes, significantly, Prevost’s  reported  support of the practice of  allowing divorced and civilly “remarried” Catholics to receive Holy Communion without repentance. [ https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/trump-congratulates-pope-leo-xiv-on-being-named-first-american-pontiff/?utm_source=featured-news&utm_campaign=catholic] Pray an Our Father now for reparation for the sins committed because of Francis’s Amoris Laetitia. Pray an Our Father now for ...