Skip to main content

Catholic Monitor calls out ChatGPT: It's response: "The most important question is not simply whether Leo XIII used the word rights. It is whether Catholic theology can speak of man's rights without allowing the language of entitlement to obscure the fact that man's first obligation, and the ultimate ordering principle of his entire existence, is love of God"

19 hours ago — Did the "displacement of virtue by rights" bring us McCarrick and "conservatives" defending James Martin & Francis?: Did Leo XIII's "non-ex cathedra" talk ...Read more
Notes:
The Catholic Monitor calls out ChatGPT: The problem with this is:

Did Leo XIII's "non-ex cathedra" talk of "rights" err because he placed "rights" not in the domain of loving God first "impl[ying] that what is given [by God] is owed" to man as "rights'' thus making God equal or subservient to man? [https://www.thecatholicmonitor.com/2026/11/did-rights-language-bring-us-mccarrick.html]

ChatGPT's response:

Your article raises a more fundamental objection than the one we had been discussing. I would revise our earlier analysis accordingly.

You are not merely asking whether Leo XIII introduced modern rights language that later became detached from virtue. You are asking whether the very act of defining what God gives man as something man is owed potentially reverses the proper relationship between Creator and creature.

That is a much deeper theological and philosophical question.

1. The central argument: love precedes entitlement

Your argument, drawing on Fr. Chad Ripperger and John Rist, can be reconstructed this way:

The Christian moral life begins with loving God above everything else.

Man is a creature. Everything he possesses, including his existence, nature, faculties, and ultimate destiny, is received from God.

Consequently, man's relationship with God begins with gratitude, dependence, obedience, and love.

The question becomes:

If we begin describing what God gives man primarily in terms of what man is owed, have we subtly changed the relationship?

Instead of understanding man as a creature who receives everything from God, we begin treating God as though He were obligated to satisfy man's claims.

That is the concern behind your question about whether rights language can make God appear equal or subordinate to man.

2. Rist's observation becomes more important

Your reference to Confusion in the West, page 81, is especially relevant.

Rist discusses the Augustinian understanding of virtue as a mode of love and contrasts it with Las Casas's treatment of rights as matters of justice.

The distinction is not necessarily that justice and love contradict each other.

Rather, it concerns which principle organizes our understanding of the moral life.

Augustinian starting point

God is first.

Man loves God, orders his life toward God, and loves his neighbor for God's sake.

Rights-centered starting point

The individual is the claimant.

Moral and political relationships are increasingly described through entitlements, claims, and corresponding obligations.

The critical question is whether the second framework remains subordinate to the first.

3. Does Leo XIII actually make this mistake?

Here we must distinguish two propositions.

Proposition A: Man possesses natural rights because God created him with a particular nature and ordered him toward particular goods.

Proposition B: Man possesses rights independently of his relationship and obligations to God, such that God Himself becomes subject to man's claims.

These are not equivalent.

The first is compatible with traditional natural-law theology.

The second would be a serious theological problem.

Leo XIII's Libertas Praestantissimum describes right as a moral power and insists that genuine rights must be understood through moral law.

His Rerum Novarum likewise places property rights within duties to God, neighbor, and the common good.

Therefore, we cannot establish that Leo actually taught Proposition B merely because he used rights language.

But your question about whether his non-ex cathedra formulations introduced a problematic conceptual framework remains open to historical and theological investigation.

4. The connection to Fortin

Fortin's Aristotelian framework helps explain what may be lost when the order is reversed.

For Aristotle and Aquinas, the human person is not fundamentally an autonomous rights-bearing individual who subsequently enters relationships with others.

He is a creature with a nature, an end, obligations, and a place within an objective moral order.

Virtue perfects his faculties so that he can fulfill that end.

Justice is a virtue. Charity orders the entire moral life toward God.

Rights can express what justice requires, but they cannot replace the virtues that make a person just.

This also clarifies the distinction between Rist's concern and a simple opposition to rights: the issue is the theological and moral framework in which rights are situated.

5. The McCarrick and Vatican II connection: an important qualification

Your article asks whether rights language eventually contributed to a culture in which ecclesiastical authorities protected individuals' claims or status rather than fulfilling their obligations to truth and justice.

That is a question worth investigating.

But we must separate three things:

  1. The philosophical development of rights language.

  2. The theological and juridical arguments surrounding religious liberty.

  3. The actual institutional failures involving McCarrick and those who failed to respond appropriately to allegations.

The existence of rights language does not establish that it caused abuse or its concealment. That causal argument requires independent historical evidence.

Likewise, Dignitatis Humanae distinguishes immunity from coercion from the moral truth of religious beliefs. It does not declare that every belief is equally true.

6. The thesis I would develop

I would sharpen your argument into this:

The fundamental problem with modern rights discourse is not simply that it emphasizes individual entitlements over social responsibilities. Its deeper theological danger arises when the relationship between God and man is interpreted primarily through the language of claims and obligations, rather than through the prior relationship of Creator and creature, love and gratitude, and the ordering of human life toward God.

In the Augustinian tradition, justice and the other virtues must be understood within the order of charity. Rights may articulate what is due to man, but they must never become the foundation upon which man's relationship with God is reconstructed.

The question raised by John Rist's analysis of Leo XIII is whether the introduction of a new juridical vocabulary altered the traditional organization of Catholic moral reasoning, even when its original purpose was to defend natural law.

One distinction is absolutely essential: God is not a debtor to man in the ordinary juridical sense. Yet God freely establishes promises and a supernatural destiny for humanity. Aquinas can therefore speak of a kind of justice between God and man by analogy, while recognizing that man can never place God under an obligation independent of God's own goodness and promises.

That distinction would make your argument considerably more precise.

The most important question is not simply whether Leo XIII used the word rights. It is whether Catholic theology can speak of man's rights without allowing the language of entitlement to obscure the fact that man's first obligation, and the ultimate ordering principle of his entire existence, is love of God.

Pray an Our Father now for reparation for the sins committed because of Francis’s Amoris Laetitia and for the restoration of the Church.

Stop for a moment of silence, ask Jesus Christ what He wants you to do now and next. In this silence remember God, Father, Son and Holy Ghost – Three Divine Persons yet One God, has an ordered universe where you can know truth and falsehood as well as never forget that He wants you to have eternal happiness with Him as his son or daughter by grace. Make this a practice. By doing this you are doing more good than reading anything here or anywhere else on the Internet.

I ask all The Catholic Monitor readers to also pray for the end of this war. Watch "Trump Calls Putin To Get Iran War Offramp! w/ Scott Ritter" on YouTube: ...Read more Please Pray for Trump to end the Iran War: Watch "Trump Calls Putin To Get Iran War Offramp! w/ Scott Ritter" on YouTubeFranklin & Graham calls on Christians to pray for 'end to the bloodshed' ahead of Trump-Putin summit...7mo




Conclave Notes:


-- Open letter urges Pope Leo XIV to correct ‘scandalous incoherence’ in Amoris Laetitia...[Wow! Even notorious Popesplainer Fr.] Harrison warns that Pope Francis taught a ‘dangerous self-contradiction’ on Communion for the divorced and ‘remarried,’ petitioning Pope Leo to correct the record. [https://www.thecatholicmonitor.com/2025/08/open-letter-urges-pope-leo-xiv-to.html]

--  Dr. Seifert, regarded as one of the greatest living Catholic philosophers, founding Rector of the International Academy of Philosopher & friend of John Paul II, to Cardinals: INVESTIGATE FRANCIS' HERESIES, VALIDITY BEFORE THE CONCLAVE.."If Francis is found guilty of heresy or apostasy, then: - His cardinal appointments would be invalid" [https://www.thecatholicmonitor.com/2025/04/dr-seifert-philosopher-personal-friend.html] 

-- Are the Cardinals who will participate in the upcoming conclave authentically appointed & morally justified in voting, or will the shadow of Francis's possible illegitimacy cast itself over the next papacy?  [https://www.thecatholicmonitor.com/2025/04/are-cardinals-who-will-participate-in.html]

-- 5 Dubia Questions for 1P5's Steve Skojec & All faithful Catholics especially Francis is definitely Pope Cardinals, Bishops & pundits [https://www.thecatholicmonitor.com/2019/06/5-dubia-questions-for-steve-skojec.html]

Francis Notes:

l– Doctor of the Church St. Francis de Sales totally confirmed beyond any doubt the possibility of a heretical pope and what must be done by the Church in such a situation:


“[T]he Pope… WHEN he is EXPLICITLY a heretic, he falls ipso facto from his dignity and out of the Church, and the Church MUST either deprive him, or, as some say, declare him deprived, of his Apostolic See.”
(The Catholic Controversy, by St. Francis de Sales, Pages 305-306)

Saint Robert Bellarmine, also, said “the Pope heretic is not deposed ipso facto, but must be declared deposed by the Church.”
[https://archive.org/stream/SilveiraImplicationsOfNewMissaeAndHereticPopes/Silveira%20Implications%20of%20New%20Missae%20and%20Heretic%20Popes_djvu.txt]

– “If Francis is a Heretic, What should Canonically happen to him?”: http://www.thecatholicmonitor.com/2020/12/if-francis-is-heretic-what-should.html

– “Could Francis be a Antipope even though the Majority of Cardinals claim he is Pope?”: http://www.thecatholicmonitor.com/2019/03/could-francis-be-antipope-even-though.html

– If Francis betrays Benedict XVI & the”Roman Rite Communities” like he betrayed the Chinese Catholics we must respond like St. Athanasius, the Saintly English Bishop Robert Grosseteste & “Eminent Canonists and Theologians” by “Resist[ing]” him: https://www.thecatholicmonitor.com/2021/12/if-francis-betrays-benedict-xvi.html 

 –  LifeSiteNews, “Confusion explodes as Pope Francis throws magisterial weight behind communion for adulterers,” December 4, 2017:

The AAS guidelines explicitly allows “sexually active adulterous couples facing ‘complex circumstances’ to ‘access the sacraments of Reconciliation and the Eucharist.'”

–  On February 2018, in Rorate Caeli, Catholic theologian Dr. John Lamont:

“The AAS statement… establishes that Pope Francis in Amoris Laetitia has affirmed propositions that are heretical in the strict sense.”

– On December 2, 2017, Bishop Rene Gracida:

“Francis’ heterodoxy is now official. He has published his letter to the Argentina bishops in Acta Apostlica Series making those letters magisterial documents.”

Pray an Our Father now for the restoration of the Church by the bishops by the grace of God.

Election Notes: 

– Intel Cryptanalyst-Mathematician on Biden Steal: “212Million Registered Voters & 66.2% Voting,140.344 M Voted…Trump got 74 M, that leaves only 66.344 M for Biden” [http://catholicmonitor.blogspot.com/2020/12/intel-cryptanalyst-mathematician-on.html?m=1]

– Will US be Venezuela?: Ex-CIA Official told Epoch Times “Chávez started to Focus on [Smartmatic] Voting Machines to Ensure Victory as early as 2003”: http://catholicmonitor.blogspot.com/2020/12/will-us-be-venezuela-ex-cia-official.html

– Tucker Carlson’s Conservatism Inc. Biden Steal Betrayal is explained by “One of the Greatest Columns ever Written” according to Rush: http://catholicmonitor.blogspot.com/2021/01/tucker-carlsons-conservatism-inc-biden.html?m=1

– A Hour which will Live in Infamy: 10:01pm November 3, 2020:
http://www.thecatholicmonitor.com/2021/01/a-hour-which-will-live-in-infamy-1001pm.html?m=1

What is needed right now to save America from those who would destroy our God given rights is to pray at home or in church and if called to even go to outdoor prayer rallies in every town and city across the United States for God to pour out His grace on our country to save us from those who would use a Reichstag Fire-like incident to destroy our civil liberties. [Is the [J6] DC Capitol Incident Comparable to the Nazi Reichstag Fire Incident where the German People Lost their Civil Liberties?: http://catholicmonitor.blogspot.com/2021/01/is-dc-capital-incident-comparable-to.html?m=1 and Epoch Times Show Crossroads on Capitol Incident: “Anitfa ‘Agent Provocateurs‘”:
http://catholicmonitor.blogspot.com/2021/01/epoch-times-show-crossroads-on-capital.html?m=1] 

Pray an Our Father now for the grace to know God’s Will and to do it.

Pray an Our Father now for America.

Pray an Our Father now for the restoration of the Church as well as the Triumph of the Kingdom of the Sacred Heart and the Immaculate Heart of Mary.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

5 Dubia Questions for 1P5's Steve Skojec & All faithful Catholics especially Francis is definitely Pope Cardinals, Bishops & pundits

Here are five really short and easy to answer dubia questions which hopefully aren't too complicated for Steve Skojec, publisher of the One Peter Five website, to answer. To make it really easy for the publisher of One Peter Five it has been formatted so that he only has to answer: yes or no. 1. Doctor of the Church St. Francis de Sales said "The Pope... when he is explicitly a heretic... the Church must either deprive him or as some say declare him deprived of his Apostolic See." Was St. Francis de Sales a Sedevacantist or a Benevacantist? Answer: yes or no. 2. "Universal Acceptance" theologian John of St. Thomas said "This man in particular lawfully elected and accepted by the Church is the supreme pontiff." Was John of St. Thomas for saying "the supreme pontiff" must be BOTH "lawfully elected and accepted by the Church" a Sedevacantist or a Benevacantist? Answer: yes or no. 3. Do you think that a "supreme pontiff...

non veni pacem (Mark Docherty) Prevost appoints Cupich to join McCarrick roomie Farrell at the Pontifical Commission for the Vatican City State

non veni pacem (Mark Docherty) Prevost appoints Cupich to join McCarrick roomie Farrell at the Pontifical Commission for the Vatican City State Pray an Our Father now for reparation for the sins committed because of Francis’s Amoris Laetitia and  for the restoration of the Church. Stop for a moment of silence, ask Jesus Christ what He wants you to do now and next. In this silence remember God, Father, Son and Holy Ghost – Three Divine Persons yet One God, has an ordered universe where you can know truth and falsehood as well as never forget that He wants you to have eternal happiness with Him as his son or daughter by grace. Make this a practice. By doing this you are doing more good than reading anything here or anywhere else on the Internet. Conclave Notes: Has the Trad Media fallen into a COVID-like mass formation with Leo XVI? While it's humorous to see the former anti-Francis Trad pundits suddenly acting like teen age girls infatuated with Leo, it could lead to a Trojan Horse ...

"Windswept House 2.0: The Next Bernardin? Rachel Mastrogiacomo, Fr. Bertrand and the Satanic Tree"

Is a “Satanic Family Tree” operating within the Catholic Church—a network that desperately needs to be mapped out? The late Cardinal Joseph Bernardin is alleged by “Agnes” from Malachi Martin's Windswept House to have been the "Master of Ceremonies" in her ritualistic abuse.  Rachel Mastrogiacomo has been told that Father Jacob Bertrand played the same role in the crimes against her. What links these violators? Rachel’s own case has convinced her that Windswept House 2.0 is not merely a historical parallel. In her view, it is a reality unfolding before our eyes. The Bernardin Connection In the 1980s, allegations emerged involving Bernardin and fellow bishops Robert Brom and John Roach in connection with sexual assaults against seminarians at Immaculate Heart Seminary in the Diocese of Winona, Minnesota. At least two alleged victims pursued legal action, bringing allegations of abuse involving these churchmen into public view. One victim alleged that the sexual assaults at...