Skip to main content

@FeserEdward..some wonder why I pay a moment’s attention to lightweights like Annett, Lewis, et al..because..they are the best the “progressive” “Catholic” side has to offer..latest illustration...

I’m aware that some wonder why I pay a moment’s attention to lightweights like Annett, Lewis, et al. The reason is precisely because they are lightweights – because it is important for all to see that they are the best the “progressive” “Catholic” side has to offer. The latest illustration of how breathtakingly unserious these people are is this remarkable exchange with today, which I’ve screencapped. In a pair of tweets, I had cited several passages from Pope John Paul II, the Catechism, the Compendium of the Social Doctrine of the Church, and Pope Francis himself, acknowledging that it is legitimate for governments to restrict immigration, and to do so for the purpose of preserving the culture and economic stability of the receiving nation. Annett’s response is, apparently, peremptorily to dismiss all of this as incompatible with Pope Francis’s Fratelli Tutti (though he never explains exactly how they are incompatible). When I ask him to confirm whether this is indeed his view, he responds that “doctrine develops” and that if I have a problem with his assertions, then I must be a Lefebvrist. When I point out in response that his position entails that not only the magisterium in general, but Pope Francis in particular, have contradicted themselves within the space of just a few years, his only reply is to fling the “Lefebvrist” accusation once again. To any reader who is neither ignorant nor blinded by ideology, I probably don’t need to point out all the problems with this. But here they are anyway. First, and again, Annett never explains how the earlier statements I cited conflict with Fratelli Tutti. He just asserts that they do. Second, he refuses even to entertain the possibility that he should accept those earlier statements and read Fratelli Tutti in light of them, rather than dismissing them out of hand. Certainly he offers no justification for refusing to do so. Third, he ignores the consideration that a true “development” of doctrine never contradicts earlier doctrine, but merely draws out implications of earlier doctrine in a way that is consistent with it. This is the teaching of St. Vincent of Lerins, of Newman, of Benedict XVI, of Vatican I, etc. etc. Fourth, even if there really were a contradiction between Fratelli Tutti and the earlier statements, he does not explain why this should cast doubt on the earlier statements rather than on Fratelli Tutti. Or how we can trust anything the magisterium says if it really has contradicted itself. Fifth, his position commits him to dismiss the teaching of the Catechism, even though the Church has never said that that teaching is obsolete. Yet he frequently labels others “dissenters” for merely objecting to the wording of the recent change to the Catechism vis-à-vis the death penalty. Annett does not explain how he can justify this double standard. Sixth, Annett never tells us how he would deal with all the obvious problems his apparent position entails. Should borders be abolished entirely? Should all immigrants be taken in, no matter how many? If not, exactly what is the upper limit, and under what conditions can immigration be halted? If so, then how is it practically even possible to take in absolutely all who want to enter, given economic limitations, security concerns, cultural cohesion, etc.? The statements I quoted from John Paul II, Francis, the Catechism, and the Compendium acknowledge these as serious issues. Exactly how do these problems disappear simply by uttering “Fratelli Tutti”? (Are those magic words or something?) Naturally, in a sane world this would all too blindingly obvious to have to be said, and a crank like Annett could be ignored entirely. But this is where we are with the “progressive” “Catholic” “intelligentsia” in 2023.
Image

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

5 Dubia Questions for 1P5's Steve Skojec & All faithful Catholics especially Francis is definitely Pope Cardinals, Bishops & pundits

Here are five really short and easy to answer dubia questions which hopefully aren't too complicated for Steve Skojec, publisher of the One Peter Five website, to answer. To make it really easy for the publisher of One Peter Five it has been formatted so that he only has to answer: yes or no. 1. Doctor of the Church St. Francis de Sales said "The Pope... when he is explicitly a heretic... the Church must either deprive him or as some say declare him deprived of his Apostolic See." Was St. Francis de Sales a Sedevacantist or a Benevacantist? Answer: yes or no. 2. "Universal Acceptance" theologian John of St. Thomas said "This man in particular lawfully elected and accepted by the Church is the supreme pontiff." Was John of St. Thomas for saying "the supreme pontiff" must be BOTH "lawfully elected and accepted by the Church" a Sedevacantist or a Benevacantist? Answer: yes or no. 3. Do you think that a "supreme pontiff...

non veni pacem (Mark Docherty) Prevost appoints Cupich to join McCarrick roomie Farrell at the Pontifical Commission for the Vatican City State

non veni pacem (Mark Docherty) Prevost appoints Cupich to join McCarrick roomie Farrell at the Pontifical Commission for the Vatican City State Pray an Our Father now for reparation for the sins committed because of Francis’s Amoris Laetitia and  for the restoration of the Church. Stop for a moment of silence, ask Jesus Christ what He wants you to do now and next. In this silence remember God, Father, Son and Holy Ghost – Three Divine Persons yet One God, has an ordered universe where you can know truth and falsehood as well as never forget that He wants you to have eternal happiness with Him as his son or daughter by grace. Make this a practice. By doing this you are doing more good than reading anything here or anywhere else on the Internet. Conclave Notes: Has the Trad Media fallen into a COVID-like mass formation with Leo XVI? While it's humorous to see the former anti-Francis Trad pundits suddenly acting like teen age girls infatuated with Leo, it could lead to a Trojan Horse ...

"Windswept House 2.0: The Next Bernardin? Rachel Mastrogiacomo, Fr. Bertrand and the Satanic Tree"

Is a “Satanic Family Tree” operating within the Catholic Church—a network that desperately needs to be mapped out? The late Cardinal Joseph Bernardin is alleged by “Agnes” from Malachi Martin's Windswept House to have been the "Master of Ceremonies" in her ritualistic abuse.  Rachel Mastrogiacomo has been told that Father Jacob Bertrand played the same role in the crimes against her. What links these violators? Rachel’s own case has convinced her that Windswept House 2.0 is not merely a historical parallel. In her view, it is a reality unfolding before our eyes. The Bernardin Connection In the 1980s, allegations emerged involving Bernardin and fellow bishops Robert Brom and John Roach in connection with sexual assaults against seminarians at Immaculate Heart Seminary in the Diocese of Winona, Minnesota. At least two alleged victims pursued legal action, bringing allegations of abuse involving these churchmen into public view. One victim alleged that the sexual assaults at...