Skip to main content

Feser's "Retraction" to Lofton: "I believe Lofton in his original video badly misunderstood my article... he insists that he did not mean to do this. I am willing, then, to take Lofton at his word, and I accept his explanation that he did not intend to defame or libel me"


Faithless FrancisChurch: My ‘Where’s Peter?’ response to Dr. Feser’s responses to my response to his idea of a partially suspended magisterium? - https://canon212.com/


Eventually, Feser walked back his “libel” claim in an article where he tries to justify his accusations against me but ultimately retracts the charges, stating he will take me “at my word.” He claims that he was accusing me of libel and defamation “in the broader, moral sense”  — as opposed to the actual definition of the terms and how his accusations were received. Catholic World Report then reproduced his blog post — although the accusatory post also remains.

I accept Dr. Feser’s retraction, although I wish he had taken me “at my word” from the beginning. The damage was done to my reputation, and the confusion he caused led many people to dismiss me without hearing my side of the story. [https://wherepeteris.com/can-the-magisterium-be-partially-suspended/]

Lofton has since explained that I have misunderstood him.  I’ll come back to that in a moment.  But it is important to note that many of Lofton’s own viewers seemed to derive from his video exactly the message that I claimed it was sending.  For example, in the chat and comments sections of the video, one reader judged my view to be “sedevacantism with extra steps”; another took it to be “an essentially Protestant view of teaching authority”; a third said “I believe Feser is proposing/defending this theory because it allows him to dissent from the Magisterium”; another regarded my view as “very obviously an ad hoc hypothesis made up to justify dissent from the Magisterium”; yet another averred that I was trying to “prove… a suspended Magisterium” and that this “makes me question whether Edward Feser deserves his teaching license after making such terrible claims”; yet another said “Please tell me Ed Feser isn’t going the Pseudo-Trad Protestant route.”  Then there were viewers who also thought that Lofton was alleging such things, but judged it “slander” for him to do so (as one viewer put it).

I submit that it was hardly unreasonable for me to judge that Lofton was guilty of defamatory innuendo and insinuation, when many of his own viewers took him to be saying exactly what I claimed he was saying.

However – and to come to the final point – Lofton insists that, despite how things appeared to me and others, in fact he intended no such thing.  And the number and vehemence of his comments over the last few days indicate that he feels very strongly about this.  I certainly understand why someone would be upset if he believes he is being misunderstood, since it happens to me quite frequently, and I believe Lofton in his original video badly misunderstood my article.

But again, he insists that he did not mean to do this.  I am willing, then, to take Lofton at his word, and I accept his explanation that he did not intend to defame or libel me. [http://edwardfeser.blogspot.com/2023/07/a-comment-on-lofton-affair.html]

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

5 Dubia Questions for 1P5's Steve Skojec & All faithful Catholics especially Francis is definitely Pope Cardinals, Bishops & pundits

Here are five really short and easy to answer dubia questions which hopefully aren't too complicated for Steve Skojec, publisher of the One Peter Five website, to answer. To make it really easy for the publisher of One Peter Five it has been formatted so that he only has to answer: yes or no. 1. Doctor of the Church St. Francis de Sales said "The Pope... when he is explicitly a heretic... the Church must either deprive him or as some say declare him deprived of his Apostolic See." Was St. Francis de Sales a Sedevacantist or a Benevacantist? Answer: yes or no. 2. "Universal Acceptance" theologian John of St. Thomas said "This man in particular lawfully elected and accepted by the Church is the supreme pontiff." Was John of St. Thomas for saying "the supreme pontiff" must be BOTH "lawfully elected and accepted by the Church" a Sedevacantist or a Benevacantist? Answer: yes or no. 3. Do you think that a "supreme pontiff...

non veni pacem (Mark Docherty) Prevost appoints Cupich to join McCarrick roomie Farrell at the Pontifical Commission for the Vatican City State

non veni pacem (Mark Docherty) Prevost appoints Cupich to join McCarrick roomie Farrell at the Pontifical Commission for the Vatican City State Pray an Our Father now for reparation for the sins committed because of Francis’s Amoris Laetitia and  for the restoration of the Church. Stop for a moment of silence, ask Jesus Christ what He wants you to do now and next. In this silence remember God, Father, Son and Holy Ghost – Three Divine Persons yet One God, has an ordered universe where you can know truth and falsehood as well as never forget that He wants you to have eternal happiness with Him as his son or daughter by grace. Make this a practice. By doing this you are doing more good than reading anything here or anywhere else on the Internet. Conclave Notes: Has the Trad Media fallen into a COVID-like mass formation with Leo XVI? While it's humorous to see the former anti-Francis Trad pundits suddenly acting like teen age girls infatuated with Leo, it could lead to a Trojan Horse ...

"Windswept House 2.0: The Next Bernardin? Rachel Mastrogiacomo, Fr. Bertrand and the Satanic Tree"

Is a “Satanic Family Tree” operating within the Catholic Church—a network that desperately needs to be mapped out? The late Cardinal Joseph Bernardin is alleged by “Agnes” from Malachi Martin's Windswept House to have been the "Master of Ceremonies" in her ritualistic abuse.  Rachel Mastrogiacomo has been told that Father Jacob Bertrand played the same role in the crimes against her. What links these violators? Rachel’s own case has convinced her that Windswept House 2.0 is not merely a historical parallel. In her view, it is a reality unfolding before our eyes. The Bernardin Connection In the 1980s, allegations emerged involving Bernardin and fellow bishops Robert Brom and John Roach in connection with sexual assaults against seminarians at Immaculate Heart Seminary in the Diocese of Winona, Minnesota. At least two alleged victims pursued legal action, bringing allegations of abuse involving these churchmen into public view. One victim alleged that the sexual assaults at...