Posts

Did the "displacement of virtue by rights" bring us McCarrick and "conservatives" defending James Martin & Francis?: Did Leo XIII's "non-ex cathedra" talk of "rights" err because he placed "rights" not in the domain of loving God first "impl[ying] that what is given [by God] is owed" to man as "rights'' thus making God equal or subservient to man?

[Leo XIII] argues that rights cannot be indiscriminately attributed to truth and error, virtue and vice. He also explains that genuine freedom must be ordered toward truth and goodness. This is important because Leo is not adopting Rousseau's general will or the secular liberal theory of autonomous individual rights. He is attempting to reclaim the language of rights by placing it under objective moral law. Vatican+1 But there is a complication. John Courtney Murray, in his analysis of Leo XIII, identifies a problem with the language of Libertas: Leo's use of the juridical concept of rights risks allowing later readers to turn a moral distinction between truth and error into an overly simplistic political principle. Murray distinguishes between the moral truth of a proposition and the separate question of how government should treat those who hold erroneous beliefs. Theological Studies Journal+1 This illustrates how a conceptual vocabulary can develop consequences beyond its or...
Recent posts