Professor de Mattei: "[B]ewilderment..reading Bishop Schneider’s assertion that it is..impossible for a reigning Pope to lose his office..for heresy, when the contrary is held by such 'great canonists & theologians'"
Bishop Athanasius Schneider's claim that popes cannot be deposed for heresy which "puzzled" renowned historian and scholar Roberto de Mattei: Rorate Caeli published a follow-up interview with Professor Roberto de Mattei, president of the Lepanto Foundation , in which the esteemed Church historian offers his assessment (full text below). While Professor de Mattei identifies much that is good in Bishop Schneider’s text, he also candidly states, “I’m somewhat puzzled by his statement: ‘ A pope cannot be deposed in whatsoever form and for whatever reason, not even for the reason of heresy .’ Monsignor Schneider denies the possibility of the loss of the papacy, while admitting this thesis has been voiced by great canonists and theologians, like Cardinal Cajetan and St. Robert Bellarmine, in favour of it.” I shared the same sense of bewilderment after reading Bishop Schneider’s assertion that it is (or should be) impossible for a reigning Pope to lose his office, even for her...